Showing posts with label empires. Show all posts
Showing posts with label empires. Show all posts

Monday, October 5, 2026

Modernity in One Hand, Shackles in the Other: My Thoughts on Colonization and Empire

QUESTION: If colonization was so beneficial, why did people fight so hard for independence?


Colonization. Empire-building. To me, they're different labels for the same basic idea: one group of people gaining power over another group and deciding how that group should live.

Throughout history, empires have often been driven by leaders who wanted more territory, more influence, wealth, or control. But leaders can't build empires alone. They need supporters. And many of those supporters aren't necessarily loyal to an ideology. Sometimes they simply choose the side they believe is winning.

empires
Image generated by CoPilot.

History gives us countless examples.

🌏Take Japanese colonial rule in Korea.

Some Koreans cooperated with the Japanese administration. Many of their fellow countrymen viewed them as traitors. Yet from the perspective of those who collaborated, the calculation may have seemed practical: "If we can't defeat them, we might as well work with them."

Korea is only one example. Similar patterns appear throughout history and across different cultures. Whenever one group gains power over another, there are often people who resist and people who adapt.

Supporters of colonial rule frequently point out the infrastructure, technology, and institutions that empires introduced. Roads, railways, schools, ports, and other forms of modernization are often cited as benefits.

But here's the question that always comes to my mind:

  • If your goal is truly to improve the lives of local people, why do they need to be ruled by outsiders in the first place?  (Ruled? OK. OPPRESSED.)
Modern conveniences do not automatically justify domination.

🌎Another example: The Bahamas.

My husband and father were both from The Bahamas.

My father grew up when The Bahamas was governed by Britain. My husband experienced both eras. He remembers Queen Elizabeth visiting the country, and he also remembers celebrating Bahamian independence.

There's no question that British influence brought certain developments and institutions. At the same time, many people in former colonies remember something else: the "attitude" that the colonizers were superior to the people who were already living there.

That part of the story shouldn't be ignored.

🌍Let's contrast the example of Ethiopia.

Ethiopia loves to brag that they were never colonized.  They remained independent although their current state of affairs leaves something to be desired.  But they could say, "Hey! At least an outsider didn't come in and screw us over! We can do bad all by ourselves."  

Support Colonization and Empire-Building.  WHY?

To me, that's where the argument for support of colonization starts to break down.  

It's similar to the attitude some tourists bring when they travel. They go somewhere new and immediately look for familiar brands, food, and customs. Instead of appreciating the culture they're visiting, they want the travel destination to resemble the home they left.

History is filled with powerful empires that once seemed unstoppable.  As if they would last forever.

  • Assyrians.
  • Babylonians.
  • Persians.
  • Macedonian Empire of Alexander the Great
  • Romans.
  • Russian Empire.
  • British Empire.
All of them exercised enormous influence. None of them lasted forever.  From Assyria to Rome, one empire took over another, and the last one fell.  Then the Russians and the British tried (and others), and they don't exist anymore either!

shackles

That's one of the recurring lessons of history. 

People may tolerate outside control for a time, but eventually many begin asking a simple question: Why should someone else govern us?

That question has fueled independence movements all over the world.

Can you understand why?

What's the value of modern conveniences if they come at the cost of freedom and self-determination?

This same skepticism shapes my view of war.

It's probably why I love “War”, that popular song by Edwin Starr**.

World War II is often remembered as a war that clearly confronted aggressive expansion and tyranny. Many conflicts that followed, however, are much more heavily debated. Citizens are often told that wars are being fought for freedom, security, patriotism, or national interests.

But I increasingly wonder how often economic interests and powerful institutions play a larger role than ordinary people are led to believe.

That's the main reason I am skeptical whenever political leaders try to present their justification for war in simple moral terms (or biblical terms).

History rarely seems that simple.

The subjects of colonization, empire-building, war, and independence are extremely complicated.

These are only my opinions, and I'm sure many people will disagree.

But agree or disagree, it's hard to ignore that one question, isn't it?

  • What's the value of modern conveniences if they come at the cost of freedom and self-determination?

If people truly benefit from being governed by others, why have so many fought so hard throughout history for independence to govern themselves?

** The Match Me Podcast. “Edwin Starr- War (HQ).” YouTube, 10 May 2012, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQHUAJTZqF0.

♦♦


FINAL NOTE: HI vs AI

I felt very strongly about stating my opinion this way, but AI disagreed:

I SAID:  (For my opening paragraph.)  "You can usually trace it to one man (or one woman on rare occasions) wanting to LORD IT OVER EVERYBODY ELSE. And the reason that person can get away with it is that they have a bunch of cronies who will support them. The cronies don't support them because they agree with the way they govern. They just choose the side they think is WINNING. It's that way everywhere in the world."

AI SAID: My statements are “emotionally powerful, ... historians would argue that empire-building often involves economics, resources, ideology, religion, security concerns, competing states, and social pressures, not just one dominant personality.”

I SAY:  I'm pretty sure you can trace it back to one person like Sargon, Nebuchadnezzar, etc.

Wednesday, October 29, 2025

Travel and History: Ten Facts About the Republic of Turkey

When you travel, it is good to know historical facts.  Modern-day Turkey, officially the Republic of Turkey, is a country strategically located between Europe and Asia, and its leaders have an integral role on the world stage. The Asian part of Turkey was at one time called Asia Minor and was a part of the ancient Roman empire. Later, Turkey became part of the Byzantine and Ottoman empires. 

Its historical, religious, political, and cultural significance, including the fact that its largest city was once the capital of three empires ~ Roman, Byzantine, and Ottoman ~ should not be discounted or minimized. The heritage of Turkey and its influence in today’s political and economic arena are intricately woven into world history and world affairs.


♦ Here are TEN FACTS About the Republic of Turkey:
  1. Mustafa Kemal Atatürk is revered as the founder of the Republic of Turkey and is also called the “Father of the Turks”.
  2. The founder of the Republic of Turkey was also nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize in 1934.
  3. The current capital city of Turkey is Ankara.
  4. Istanbul was once the capital of three empires: Roman, Byzantine, and Ottoman.
  5. Istanbul was once historically known by the name Constantinople.
  6. “Turkey entered World War II in 1945 on the side of the Allies, who secured an agreement that Turkey would become a democracy.”
  7. Even though Britain or the UK has voted to exit the EU (“Brexit”), Turkey wishes to be accepted as a member state of the European Union (EU).
  8. NATO (the North Atlantic Treaty Organization) is an international alliance between European and North American countries and Turkey is a member state.
  9. Hagia Sophia, Blue Mosque, Topkapi Palace and Galata Tower are all famous buildings in Turkey; must-see places for any traveler or visitor. The Topkapi Palace is a UNESCO World Heritage Site?
  10. The Independent published a list of Turkey’s 7 most popular cities that attract tourists. Even though Cappadocia is located in Central Turkey and is mentioned in the Bible, this city was NOT on their list.
(Content previously published at Virily.)


Related Links:
* * *FOR YOUR READING LIST (if you enjoy a good mystery):














*





Monday, August 2, 2021

The Origin of Brutal Regimes is Ancient History

“‘Violence is the common origin of all regimes. Life, discussion, and political choice occur only against a background of violence.’ ~ Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908–1961), “Humanism and Terror”

Image: "The Legend of Sargon (The Goddess Ishtar Appears to Sargon, the Gardener's Lad)" By the contemporary artist, Edwin J. Prittie"

**
I AGREE with Mr. Merleau-Ponty. Ever notice when most people speak of a regime they usually describe it as brutal? The use of violence is unrestrained and motivated by either the lust for power (control over a landmass and the people who live on it) and/or a desire for revenge (action required against some wrong done to them). The blood of innocents (and of some who are guilty) must be shed for the rise of the empire and must continue to be shed in defense of the realm.


People have free will and know the difference between good and evil. They choose evil. I blame Sargon. He started it. Many historians give him credit for being the first empire-builder.  I trace the origin of brutal regimes back to him.  He may be written in the historical records as The Great or The Magnificent but I say the man was nothing but a troublemaker and a hell-raiser.  (NOTE: Sharp contrast. Abraham never lifted a finger to build an empire or become ruler, yet he is the father of many nations. God called him out of the land that Sargon bathed in blood building his empire.)

The origin of brutal regimes may be ancient history, but sadly, brutal regimes still exist today all over the world.
  • Do you have an opinion, one way or the other about, the Merleau-Ponty quote? (Or about my insightful and simplistic philosophical points of view?)
♦ ♦


Links of Interest:







Sponsors